Pelham Smithers Associates
Wed 25 Oct 2023 - 10:00 BST
Pelham discussed Japan's interest rate dilemma, emphasising that it’s externally influenced rather than self-created and cautioned against a negative perspective highlighting that risk does not equate to certainty. He presented a base-case scenario where U.S. interest rates rise but not as quickly as feared, the Japanese economy stabilises, JGB yields level out, and the yen weakens moderately. This, he noted, might necessitate a short-term softening of share prices. Pelham also highlighted Japan's vulnerability to even minor interest rate fluctuations. He pointed out the unusual performance of the Japanese stock market this year of 20%+ growth, attributing this to Japan's unique demographics. The conversation explored Japan's substantial national debt, standing at 225% of GDP, and the need to combat it through inflation rather than tax hikes. The discussion shifted to Japan's monetary policy, involving large asset purchases, but with limited success in increasing bank lending and concerns about the valuation of the Japanese stock market and the potential for short-term earnings growth. He expressed worries about Japan's exports and the challenges they face despite a weakening yen. Retail sales were discussed in relation to inflation, as well as job market dynamics and the discrepancy between high-street and postal inflation. Finally Pelham delved into GDP growth and the importance of considering nominal GDP, he raised concerns about misleading economic data and potential policy errors.
Recently, the IMF raised its 2023 GDP growth forecast for Japan from 1.4% to 2.0%. Given that the Japanese economy grew by 1.8% in the 2023 H1, this implies it should grow faster in the H2 (2.2%) than in the H1.
This optimism and encouragement from overseas have impacted sentiment at home, with the Bank of Japan also expected to raise its assessment. This in turn is leading to higher bond yields in anticipation of an ending of ZIRP.
However, is the Japanese economy really accelerating. Or have we passed peak growth already?
If we have, could the Bank of Japan be set to raise rates into a slowing economy?
And if it does, would this matter?